christian domestic discipline testimonialsfdep southwest district
Does anyone have advice? Anonymous, christianddgroup.typepad.com, 13. Here is a tasty quote AGAINST wife-spanking: Jim Alsdurf, a forensic psychologist who evaluates and treats sexual psychopaths and is the author of a book on abuse in Christian homes, says CDD isnt about religionits an outlet for emotionally disturbed men with intimacy deficits. Next Saturday, this wife was real quiet. Somewhere out there, a guy is trotting around his living room on all fours, wearing a leather thong and nothing else but a saddle on his back. My father could sit on his self worshipping bottom the whole time my mother suffered through pregnancy and birth, he did not have to dread horrific genital pain, he sure got a thrill that she did. And the whole of sub-saharan Christian Africa. I can also say , please sir may I go to bed without my nightgown and thats me asking to be intimate, Ben almost always says yes. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. We had many problems. Most men want their wives to be happy. He warned me many times and told me to stop or I would regret it. and going through Judges 4:9 all the way to Eph 5:23 and 1Tim 2:12). And guess what? [redacted] said Jamin has used pornography as a means of punishment towards [redacted]. Then my dad and my husband had coffee while I stood in the corner and dad talked to my husband about being head of household. Domestic Disciplining is consistent with the natural instincts of men and women which is why it has been practiced for so long, and why it will keep coming back over and over whether you like it or not. Im also arguing that you continue to blow bullshit and try to make it sound like wisdom. Do you find that you need it as much or less over the last 30 years? The best way to get help for high risk cases of domestic abuse is to ring the DV Hotline in your country. So-called Christian domestic discipline occurs in a marriage when one or both partners use biblical support to rationalize an unscriptural and un-Christian lifestyle. Instead, I understand that person to be trapped in a self-destructive pattern of addiction. It is interesting to note that a our lone wolf twister of Scripture is not content to merely advocate for and justify the abuse of wives (again, all application of coercive authority is abuse). science is wrong on domestic violence because you said so? mysterious death, disappearance, ending up in a vegetative state in a nursing home) and been assured that they are powerful, well funded, technically and legally savvy and any efforts to move and change her identity are futile. How about at your own home growing up, was your mother spanked? When we finally got to my parents, I figured I was safe so I started again. My sister and brother continue to suffer as a result. You are going to have to move to a place of forgiveness. In the 70s went screaming for Radio Talk Show Host to interview abused women in the church; we havent come far have we? I cant support you in that. Most of the time, my husband is like, Sure, baby. I suggested you start with an interlinear to see how the Greek is worded just for starters but I keep forgetting you need phallic permission. 13 For Adam was first formed, then Eve. In this first article we will demonstrate how the practice of domestic discipline aligns perfectly with Biblical principles and commands regarding marriage. And no, the experiences, however bad, do not nullify the word of God. Anne Garboczi Evans, that is terrible! Weenie-chopping? So: Do you see both yourself and your partner as people who need physical discipline? He told me I was never to wear such slutty clothing and made me throw them all away (after beating my bottom). Was your church part of a particular denomination? I offer personal advice and mentorship in marriage to men or women who contact me. It never occurred to me to suppose that 100pinkapples might not be a Christian. If nothing else, take that away with you. If not which of you 2 does? I know for a long time I did not consider myself a battered or abused wife. You think you are just but you are what the Bible calls a mocker., 1 Kings 18:27: It came about at noon, that Elijah mocked them and said, Call out with a loud voice, for he is a god; either he is occupied or gone aside, or is on a journey, or perhaps he is asleep and needs to be awakened., No one is tricked or trapped into that, even if you seem to have the concerning desire to save people from themselves because it just cant be right.. BeenThereDoneThat, No, actually, you cant. For instance, those who practice domestic discipline often cite scripture that calls for wives to submit to their husbands. I find your style offensive. The notion of automatic mental vulnerability and the basically mandatory victim status of the woman. In an abusive home, children do not have a sense of a normal healthy marriage, so thismodeling of abusive behaviorcould affect generations. I knew at seventeen that I would rather be dead than married to a Christian man. In the case you need to discipline your wife while on a voyage, you know you can do so without attracting attention. It contains articles on spanking in marriage, as well as advice on leading the home. When we protect and defend abused wives, we are also protecting and defending their children and future generations. On the opposite, I hope that we will maintain an environment in which we can all live our lives in our own terms, however this obviously doesnt seem to be your agenda, you seem decided to fix society and down-look at people who think in a way radically different than you. Does the power differential matter? Why are women in a similar, and even more benign relationship seen as victims, non-free agents, and not capable of the free thought it might take to walk out the door? I would encourage you to visit the following site, especially their blog section 1. You can get in my face and scream it, and it still wont be a proof. Who cares? Keep asking, keeping phoning, keep knocking on doors. My mother ruled the house and henpecked my father. Are there other women is situations this dire? What Is The Husbands Role In Christian Domestic Discipline? Christian Domestic Discipline, wife spanking, Christian Patriarchy Movement, Spanking of Adult Children, Denominational Practices and teachings Two summers ago, I received a phone call from a pastor who shared his growing concern about wife-spanking in his family of churches. (You cannot find a single Bible verse that says that never married adult women must submit to a man because there is no such concept. Regarding your link, Id actually view the success of 50 shades as a consequence of so many women not having an example of real masculinity in their lifeso they go for the fake, which is Christian Gray or whoever. . In, the language of our marriage, in referring to this lifestyle choice, I tell my husand that I love being his baby. The professionals in DV services are trained (or should be trained!) He/she was saying that men truly working with the wisdom of God understand everything, both Gods justice, and the theories of their counterparts, rather than only understanding their own theories and thinking that everybody else is a fool (like you do). The ones who claim they enjoy it have psychological issues, but its not due to wanting to be abused that is sick. There is plenty of information out there, why dont you do your research instead of spreading intolerance and hatry. (the link to their blog is currently on the upper left hand side of the page): When you first commented on here, I was prepared to hear you out I know someone personally who has fetishes, and hes admitted to me that can be a struggle for him in his marriage. For anyone wanting many more articles, and explanations, and rebuttals to the sexist views If you are currently living (or have lived) the Christian Domestic Discipline lifestyle and you would like to share how it has helped your marriage or relationship, please email your story and mention that you wish to share your experiences with other people. (Both know of the relationship my husband and I have, as we have talked with them about the joys of a CDD relationship.). Jamin was holding up his left hand and motioning his right hand into his left hand as he explained [redacted] actions. And, isnt that just your whole argument? Gen 2:18 And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him. We are commanded to submit to them. I am doing much better now and am very glad to be removed from all that. 2. Its not physically another person, but it is mentally and emotionally. Even when we get punished when we think we didnt do anything wrong we cant be disobedient. It is not for you to determine someones path of recovery. Even interpreting the Bible in an incorrect way as you do to read authority into the Bible, your view only addresses married mothers, and is not applicable or workable for never-married women, widows, the infertile, the childfree or the divorced. He has already had too much of your life. When he was done, he did not say one word. Many of them are even written by women in these relationships. For keep in mind that you are in a very difficult position in that you are promoting an ideology which is against nature. Male headship is followed all over the world. Dad took off my slacks and panties and handed the strap to my husband. And the thought of a Pentecostal being in to kinky, spanking fetishes is hilarious. (Ill let her tell you one way or the other, if she wants to.). Male headship is followed all over the world.. I had to compose myself and return to where everyone else was knowing that they all knew what just happened. And your friend, of course, if she is able to. Jamin wanted me to take a look at his finger nails because he was said his finger nails were too short to leave any marks. Carrie, what conclusion did Pat Robertson come up with to help this husband? Lets treat adults like adult and lets avoid the temptation of playing the role of God. Shes also been provided several examples of those that have tried to leave (e.g. If a principle were biblical, it could and work equally for all people. No fool in his right mind would buy this as a legitimate way to have a relationship, Alsdurf says. [redacted] did not report the incident right away because she was afraid of retaliation and did not know what to do. Its the word of God: Daisy, thank you for your usual good work in countering those who, like the satan, abuse and twist Scripturein the present case to justify the abuse of women. Lone, there are a few Biblical objections to role playing, S& M, and the like. He blathered on in his books or blogs about how men should be heroic and defend women and girls like the men who gave up their seats on the Titanic, but he was sexually assaulting a teen-aged girl for years, and stalking her! WebThen I went to college and met my husband James, and became a Christian. Justice is not a consensual relationship. Founded in 2010, Thought Catalog is owned and operated by The Thought & Expression Company, Inc. For over a decade, we've been at the bleeding edge of media, pioneering an infrastructure for creatives to flourish both artistically and financially. Ahhh, proof-texting. christian domestic discipline A History of the Corporal Discipline of Women January 11, 2023 In this third and final part of my three-part series on Christian Domestic Discipline, we explore how the practice of domestic discipline continue through the middle-ages and even into America up until the mid-20th century. States have laws restricting consent to marry a person who is already married. Im the one who recommend it, it really helps the relationship for me. Or are women and little girls suppose to hurt to make Christian men feel good, I lived this life, it hurts so much. Retha I missed Dark Childs comment. He wasnt hitting me with closed fists or objects. I am pretty sure that we will continue this lifestyle for as long as we live because it has done wonders for our marriage. . This makes it all more more important for the victim and her supporters to be persistent in calling for help, and politely pressing for the workers and the justice system to do what they can do. It seems that both of these components make it much more likely for a woman to be the victim of domestic violence/wife spanking. As someone that has been burned and sexually abused I can say there is nothing worse then intercourse with a misogynist, men that go on about male headship, female submission to men. Was your church aware of what was going on? (1 Cor 7:4), the husband does not have authority over his own body, but the wife does. Building an adult-adult relationship with parents is a difficult transition, but it can be done. I am in my early 30s and this past 4th of July I was there and we had a bit of an argument. Give me a break. It is insidious that this practice has continued in the name of God and Christianity. And people, please take seriously my point about not thinking of other folk when you are in bed. I do not find your opinion disguting, but I find this tactic disgusting. Our marriage is energized. ;) I am neither kinky, nor a doormat. Did you go straight from home to marriage without any schooling? At the very least, the reality is miles away from what you are trying to make it, please do your research. Im very grateful to Lauren for her e-mailand being willing to shed more light into this abusive practice so that we can have more understanding of what she and many others are going through. For, right now most people in this thread seem to be in a bubble of self-righteousness that tends to look ridiculous from the outside, especially when the scientists obviously know nothing about the object of their analysis. A Lone Voice, you have major issues with women having the right to say NO to men. Do not expect her to be silent through this experience though. The fact is: The Lord quoted scripture to the Pharisees, and floored them, and the Sadducees for that matter. Why are you so eager to judge that which you do not understand and have obviously no interest in understanding ? You have decided that you are better than everybody, however humility and open-mindness are the beginning of knowledge. I think he made his point. Just about to board the 2nd leg of my flight to Chicago. Wacky science isnt fooling anyone, even if people are not always able to verbalize it, they feel within themselves that something is wrong and this autism makes them explode at some point.. Out of our wounds flow compassion, understanding, & grace. My reaction then was much like most women and like the worlds view of submission. I do not want a world in which wife beating makes a come back with rage. She was there every step of the way. That is inappropriate and now you are now in the doghouse. And, isnt that just your whole argument? It is very disturbing to read. Christianity is about inspiring free hearts, not forcing them with laws. But having said all that, you have something practical, but difficult, which you must do. I had my hands up and she walks into me. Jamin was not told about the allegations made against him by [redacted] to me. But he is a wonderful, loving husband and father, a great provider and well, being in charge just suits him. No, Im sorry, you are acting heartless. I submit that, no matter what, 100pinkapples is our sister, and that Lone Voice is not to be received as a brother. So while I believe that Biblically speaking, married couples do have a great amount of freedom in how and when they make love, that does not extend to humiliation and injury. Then stop discussing it here and promoting it. What was your parents response about the spanking? In addition, they were ostracized by the faith community which was one of the few means of assistance for the poor. Your attempt to broad brush all who disagree with you as feminists does not work. The church needs to know this is going on. Pat Robertson is another known figure in Christiandom who has said some shocking statements about how husbands should treat wives. You take it up with him., the wife and the husband having power or authority over each others bodies is in the context of them not refusing each other conjugal relations (due benevolence). Only to find out that my husband has talked to my father about this lifestyle and has his blessing. And yet. But he never swore, or acted out of control. Your inability to understand your counterpart speaks volume and certainly does not honour you. Gods judgments from Gen 3:14 3:17 set matters straight, and gave the man more work into the bargain. So-called Christian domestic discipline occurs in a marriage when one or both partners use biblical support to rationalize an unscriptural and un-Christian lifestyle. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Do not do it in any degrading way; some articles suggest not to spank children with special needs; Im sure thats some kind of grey area christian domestic discipline A History of the Corporal Discipline of Women January 11, 2023 In this third and final part of my three-part series on Christian Domestic Discipline, we explore how the practice of domestic discipline continue through the middle-ages and even into America up until the mid-20th century. Just chalk it up to your personal preference and call it a day. Although it is still a hot topic between parents throughout the web. Its happenin. Daisy: I dont have issues with men. Then in your next paragraph: Men are not the loving protectors that some claim that they should be Er It is almost enough to make me hope that the doctrine of eternal conscious punishment is true, at least for some whose evil actions in this life are especially egregious. I WASNT SCARED!!!! Christian Domestic Discipline, wife spanking, Christian Patriarchy Movement, Spanking of Adult Children, Denominational Practices and teachings Two summers ago, I received a phone call from a pastor who shared his growing concern about wife-spanking in his family of churches. Or were they connected with teachings similar to an article I wrote, Wife Undermines Her Husbands Authority in Front of Children, He DisciplinesHer? With regards to this new craziness, deepen your research and you will find that it was very common for men to spank their wives, to the point that archives of advertising campaigns referring to this then cultural norm can easily be found online. Finally, I would suggest that the fix you are suggesting are the reasons domestic discipline has been making a come back lately and is here to stay. So, it is meekness, it is not weakness. We continue to call it abuse, despite the fact that it happens between two consenting* adults, and we continue to prosecute those teachers who abuse their students. WebJennas Punishment Spanking (Christian Domestic Discipline Marriage #1) During a disagreement, Jenna storms out of the house without telling her husband where she's going. Reading this comment section is like reading a handbook of how liberal thinkers (and do not assume that I am a conservative), go about turning people who think differently than them into mentally sick people. If you are truly interested in learning more about that folly, there are plenty of websites and blogs and practicers on the internet. I disagree with secular feminists on most topics and am not politically correct., (Speaking of being Un-Politically Correct: You have made my point. The whole verse says: 1Cor 7:4 The wife hath not power of her own body, but the husband: and likewise also the husband hath not power of his own body, but the wife. And it goes on: 1Cor 7:5 Defraud ye not one the other, except it be with consent for a time, that ye may give yourselves to fasting and prayer; and come together again, that Satan tempt you not for your incontinency.